Monthly Archive


To install or not

My recent posts about the NTFSsecurity module drew a comment that the cmdlets in the module couldn’t be used because they’re not installed on every server. This raises the question - to install or not.

Windows systems have a huge array of PowerShell cmdlets available:

- those from the PowerShell team that form the “core” of PowerShell

- other Windows teams such as the Networking and Storage teams

- the modules that come with optional features such as AD, DNS or DHCP

- the RSAT tools – though they overlap with the cmdlets from the optional features

- modules from the PowerShell gallery – some Microsoft and others from the community

- modules from third party vendors


What I install on a system depends on what the system is supposed to do and what I need to know about the system.


A domain controller probably doesn’t need much extra PowerShell functionality installed as it should a single purpose (I include DNS) system.

Similarly, a dedicated Exchange or SQL Server system doesn’t need much else installed – though I may install the DBAtools on a SQL box.


A File server is likely to have a mass of NTFS permissions to work with and the NTFSsecurity module would be very useful.

Jump off / admin servers are where I’d likely to install a lot of functionality that can reach out to other systems.


The question to install or not doesn’t have a simple answer - some organizations categorically forbid the installation of external software for instance - as it depends on your organization, your needs and what you want to accomplish.


As usual with IT the only answer is – IT DEPENDS!

Comments are closed.